I like Jessica’s better.

Jessica Can Go Sit Down In A Corner And Stop Clowning Herself Like On The Real!!!Mariah Is The Best Ever And Always Will Be, Jessica Is Some Shit That Clogged Up My Toilet. Jessica And Any Other Artist Should Never TRY And Top Mariah!!

Can’t Jessica just sing a song that she feels like singing, everyone uses other singers songs and when Jessica uses it, its a big deal grow up!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She is no Mariah Carey but i like her’s better as well!!!!!!!!

omg, Jess can’t compare! Mariah is officially the queen of Christmas music. Her new album “Merry Christmas II You” is an instant classic! Mimi rules :)

The Mariah Carey song, which she helped write, became an instant Christmas classic. Jessica Simpson song ripped from Mariah and isn’t near as good and vocally Jessica Simpson isn’t near the class of Mariah.

jessica is like a total bitch trying to rip off the diva mariah! like who the hell does she think she is she can’t sing for shit!!!!! jessica needs to die and i hope columbia records like sues her dumb blonde copycat ass!

There isn’t a problem with singing other people’s songs, if you give them credit. But taking someone’s song, changing it a little bit, and trying to pass it off as your own is wrong. And no, Jessica Simpson cannot compare to Mariah Carey in terms of beauty or talent.

Give Jessica a break man! Similar, yes. Identical, no way. I actually prefer Jessica’s to Mariah’s. If Mariah is not complaining, why should we. We do live in a free country where copyright laws are checked prior to the release of a song for copyright infringement.

NO ONE could ever duplicate Mariah. I do not care for Jessica’s version at all. She clearly is a class b singer (if that). She should have created her own song instead of using someone else’s. That’s the problem today, no one is original.

Mariah’s is a classic; Jessica’s seriously made my ears hurt.

You cant top Mariah…she has amazing vocals and Jessicas version sounds like she is singing with a mistletoe shoved somewhere that it shouldnt be. Jessicas cd will flop, its obviously not an original song. If you are writing a christmas song, you dont copy one from one of the highest grossing christmas cd’s!!! AND if you do copy it, dont claim it as your own.

foolish

I love Mariahs song, however, i do not think Jessica’s song sounds like mc’s at all.

Jessica Simpson is absolutely amazing<3 Mariah Carey cannot even compare to the overall success that Jessica has achieved. She married a kid half of her age. Gross.

Wait…Laura…you think JESSICA SIMPSON is more successful than Mariah Carey? That is laughable at best. Mariah Carey has had more #1 hits (18) than any other solo artist in history. Has Jessica Simpson had any? The girl is famous for not knowing what tuna is. I dont even mind this song but it is a blatant rip off, and she will never be able to compare to Mariah.

Jessica Simpson’s song def. sounds similar to Mariah’s, however Jessica is a fan of Mariah and this could possibly be her just showing it. Mariah can sing way better no doubt, n had more success, but who r we to dump on Jessica? has anyone here made an album?

[...] post: Jessica Simpson Copycats Mariah Carey | Allie is Wired ← Did Jessica Simpson Pay for Her Own $100000 Ring? | [...]

I think that Jessica Simpson is a real fan of MC’s and believe that maybe this is a hommage to her icon, i quite like her song, im not saying it’s better than Mariah’s not by a long shot but lets be honest how many christmas songs can be put in the same league as All i want for christmas is you anyway? i say good job Jessica for creating a merry little jingle this christmas :)

[...] the record, I was on Team Jessica when she had her singing career. But ever since she tried to go head to head with Mariah Carey in the Christmas song wars, I JUST CAN’T. I mean, “I Think I’m [...]