The final 3 contestants are left to battle it out for the title of American Idol. This week the contestants got to go home to be praised and adored by their communities. During their return home, the judges texted their song choices for the contestants to sing this week, along with an additional tune chosen by the contestants.

Kara DioSTFU and Randy Jackson worked together to chose John Mayer‘s “Daughters” song for Casey James. (I am guessing Randy drew the short straw.) Simon Cowell picked Leonard Cohen’s version of “Hallellujah” for Lee Dewyze. This was head smacking for me as Tim Urban sang it earlier this year and the tune is losing its sacred appeal for me. Many, many other artists have taken this song and made their own. Give it a rest.

Ellen picked a Paul McCartney tune for Crystal. “Maybe I’m Amazed” gave her a chance to get rid of the guitar and show diversity. The sitting on the stairs thing was a bit corny, but for Idol it works. The performance received a standing ovation from most.

Bowersox’s choices in song was “Come to My Window” by Melissa Etheridge. She brought the guitar back and strapped a harmonica to her neck and belted it out. There wasn’t much change to it, but I think it’s who she is.

Lee Dewyze sang “Hallelujah” after Simon was trying to give him a song to “have a moment.” I may not have agreed with song choice and Lee is a bit Danny Gokey for me, but this defiantly a moment for him.

Simon was left smiling, the crowd was standing and cheering and Randy was fighting to give his critique. All four judges agreed that he delivered. It’s going to be no surprise that Crystal and Lee will be the last two standing.

His personal song choice was “Simple Man.” I am a huge Lynyrd Skynyrd fan and I was a bit wary when I heard he was tackling one the best songs. Again, there wasn’t much interpretation, but it was good for Lee and his persona.

Casey James, hate to say it, but it really doesn’t bode well when he has struggled on and off through the season. He managed to dethrone Big Mike last week, but I doubt his work tonight will be even close to being able to shake Crystal or Lee.

I think the fact that everyone mentioned the words “no climax” sums it up.

Putting him up first was not good for as his performance was buried thanks to be so cruise ship after dinner performance. Good bye Casey. Hello FINAL TWO!